Have You Ever Heard Of “The Atlantis Of New Jersey”?
In the late 1800s, Tucker's Island was home to a lighthouse, lifeguard station, two hotels, twenty summer cottages, and a community meetinghouse.
Every year, the ocean crept further and further up the beach. The hotels closed in 1910, and later collapsed and washed away; the lighthouse fell in 1927.
The island was located east of Tuckerton between Beach Haven and Little Egg Inlets.
You can get more details on this story here.