A Chatham Pizzeria You’ve Probably Never Heard of Just Made a Best-in-America List

Let me ask you a hard question: Who makes the best pizza in New Jersey? Earlier this year, we hosted the Pizza Playoffs on the radio station, where we asked you to vote on the best pizza around the Jersey Shore.

Places like Fratellie's, Bella's, Zachary's, and Pies on 37 were all hailed as having some of the best pizza around, but the winner of our Pizza Playoff was also ranked as one of the best pizza places in the entire country.

2 New Jersey Pizza Shops Crowned The Best Pizzerias In America

In fact, 2 pizza places from Jersey made the list, and it's easy to see what sets them apart!

Get our free mobile app

Brooklyn Square Ranked Among The Best Pizza Shops In America

Brooklyn Square earned a top spot on USA Today's list of the best pizza spots in the country. And if you've ever had a pie from here, it's easy to see why. They make pizzas that are massive but not over-the-top heavy, and the classic square pie makes for the perfect pizza night.

Brooklyn Square has locations all over the Jersey Shore, so grabbing a pie is super easy!

Bucky's Pizza In Chatham Earned A Top Spot On USA Today's List Of Best Pizzerias

Then there's Bucky's Pizza in Chatham. I'll be honest, I've never heard of this place before, but after looking into it, I need to give them a try.

What sets Bucky's Pizza apart from other pizzerias is the crust. Bucky's Pizza makes its crust out of fermented sourdough, giving it an incredibly unique and one-of-a-kind taste.

Bucky's Pizza is a newcomer to the pizza game in Jersey, but they are definitely making an impact, being called not just one of the best pizza spots in Jersey, but in all of America.