Hidden Mountain Town Pizzeria Crowned Best In New Jersey

Quick, tell me where to get the best pizza in New Jersey!

On the spot, it can be a hard question to answer, especially in New Jersey; we have so many amazing mom-and-pop shops that serve up some pretty amazing pies.

READ MORE: Here's What's Taking The Place Of The Old TGI Friday's In Toms River

Dave Portnoy Picks His Favorite Pizza Place In NJ

According to Dave Portnoy, the best slice in New Jersey is DeLucia's in Raritan, at least that's what Dave said after he took his One Bite Challenge to one of Jersey's oldest pizza shops.

A Local Favorite: The Anchor Inn In Ocean Gate, NJ

Personally, I'm a huge fan of a bar pie from The Anchor Inn in Ocean Gate. Their onion and pepper pie will blow your mind without blowing up your wallet.

Get our free mobile app

Food Network Names The Best Pizza In New Jersey

Recently, though, experts at Food Network set out across the Country to try and find the best pizza in each state, and when it comes to Jersey, they picked a hidden gem in a little mountain town.

The History Behind This Sussex County, NJ Pizza Shop

Located in the small town of Newtown, you'll find one of the oldest pizzerias in Sussex County.

The shop has been in the same family for over half a century, and is owned by two brothers who learned to make their pizza dough in the heart of Brooklyn. Giving their pizzas a unique and authentic taste.

Dominick’s Italian Restaurant Named NJ’s Best Pizza

According to the Food Network, the best pizza slice in New Jersey can only be found at Dominick's Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria.

Must-Try Pies: The Drunken Grandma and Palermo

The Drunken Grandma is a popular pie; a thin-crust pizza topped with vodka sauce, fresh mozz, and basil.

People also rave about the Palermo Pie, a square, thin-crust pie topped with marinara, red onion, and a special blend of herbs and spices.