NJ’s Top Ice Cream Shop Is One Of The Best In America

There's nothing better than getting an ice cream cone at the Jersey Shore, and whether you're a soft serve kind of person or a hard scoop person one thing we can all agree on is that ice cream tastes better in Jersey!

My wife is prone to Kohrs Bros, specifically the orange vanilla twists, whereas I'm more of a Mister Softee kind of guy.

Get our free mobile app

But where do you get the best ice cream in New Jersey? It's a big question, and fortunately, the travel experts at 24/7 Tempo have the answer.

Personally, I would have thought Jersey's best ice cream shop would be the Sweet Shack.

Located off 9 in Bayville, it may be one of the coolest ice cream shops in Ocean County.

Sadly though, it's not considered Jersey's best place for ice cream.

READ MORE: Colonial Bakery Will Make A Comeback In Lavallette In 2025!

If not there, then where? Maybe you're thinking it's Mrs. Walkers in Toms River, or Yellow Brick Road in Brick, or maybe even the Custard King in South Jersey.

Believe it or not, none of those places are being called NJ's top ice cream shop for 2024.

What Is NJ's Top Ice Cream Shop For 2024?

You'll have to make your way to North Jersey, specifically Jersey City to try Jersey's best ice cream shop because according to 24/7 Tempo the best ice cream in Jersey comes from Torico Ice Cream.

Founded in 1968, Toricio started out serving shaved ice and sorbets and eventually made the move into making homemade ice cream as well.

The shop is family-owned and operated and can still be found on Erie Street in Jersey City.

Have you ever been to Torico? Is It really the best ice cream in Jersey?