This New Ortley Beach Bakery May Have The Best Crumb Cake On The Island

I really need to open my eyes more often. A while back, Fumosa Brothers Bakery closed in Ortley Beach. More on that here.

A New Bakery Has Replaced Fumosa, And The Crumb Cake Is Amazing

Get our free mobile app

Since then, it looks like another bakery has moved in, and I'm literally just now realizing it. Some people on social media are claiming that this new bakery has some of the best crumb cake at the Jersey Shore.

Typically, those are fighting words in Jersey, and most people will automatically tell you that Mueller's has the shore's best crumb cake. And I won't argue with that. I love going to Mueller's; the crumb cake just hits different. But there are still a ton of great bakeries that make crumb cake that's pretty dang good.

Sophie G's Bakery In Ortley, NJ, Makes The Best Crumb Cake At The Shore

According to the Instagram user Joshsfoodnstuff, Sophie G's Bakery, which is new to the Ortley Beach area, may make the best crumb cake on the island. A bold statement, but the crumb cake does look really good.

I'll be honest, that's some darn good-looking crumb cake, and both the regular and the blueberry crumb cake got more than nine points. Have you been to Sophie G's? Do you also think they have some of the best crumb cake at the shore?

Where Do You Go For The Best Crumb Cake At The Shore?

Everyone has their favorite spot, and according to Jersey Shore locals, these are some of the best places to check out for amazing New Jersey crumb cake