One NJ School’s New Cell Phone Policy Has Parents Fighting Back

New Jersey’s new school cell phone rules are officially becoming a reality, and if you thought getting thousands of teenagers to put their phones away all day was going to happen without a little controversy, think again.

One school district is already getting some serious pushback from parents over how it plans to enforce the state's new bell-to-bell cell phone ban.

The issue isn't really the ban itself. It's an app.

Get our free mobile app

District officials want to give students the option of installing an app called The Commons on their phones. Once students arrive at school, the technology limits what they can do with their devices during the school day.

That immediately raised privacy concerns among some parents.

New Jersey Parents Question School Cell Phone App

A petition opposing the plan has collected hundreds of signatures. One of the biggest concerns is the app's use of geofencing and whether students would essentially be required to carry a location-tracking app on their personal devices.

Parents also raised questions about cybersecurity, student privacy, and how much information a third-party company could potentially collect.

Here's an important detail, though. The app is not mandatory.

Students who don't use The Commons can simply shut off their phones and leave them in their backpack or locker for the school day.

Students who do use the app can keep their phones. Internet-connected features are restricted during school hours, but calling capabilities remain available in case of an emergency.

That distinction apparently wasn't clear when the plan was first announced, which contributed to some of the backlash, according to NJ.com.

READ MORE: NJ's 25 Lowest Scoring Math Districts 

Spotswood Schools Respond to Cell Phone Privacy Concerns

Spotswood Public Schools, which serves about 1,600 students, is at the center of it all.

Superintendent Jeffrey Bicsko acknowledged the concerns and reached out to families to clarify that downloading The Commons would be optional.

The app is expected to use geofencing to activate restrictions around 7:30 a.m. and remove them around 2:11 p.m.

There may also be limited exceptions. Students with IEPs or specific needs could potentially keep access to certain apps, including translation services, calming tools, or blood sugar monitoring apps.

The whole debate highlights one of the challenges created by New Jersey's new statewide policy.

The state says students can't use personal devices during the school day, but individual districts still have to figure out exactly how they'll make that happen.

Some schools are turning to those lockable phone pouches we've been hearing so much about. Others are telling students to shut their phones off and keep them in lockers or backpacks.

Spotswood had previously used classroom phone holders. Students could grab their phones between classes and use them at lunch. The new bell-to-bell requirement means that system isn't enough anymore.

District officials believe the app offers a compromise because students can still have their phones nearby for emergencies.

For parents, however, the bigger question may be whether enforcing a cell phone ban should involve installing software on a student's personal device at all.

And given how attached we've all become to our phones, I have a feeling this won't be the last New Jersey district to face that debate.